Robert Downey Jr as Sherlock Holmes
Dec. 22nd, 2009 12:16 amOfficial trailer here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUQbmFAE5WI
Ok, so.
I adore RDJ. I think he's brilliant. I've loved just about everything I've ever seen him do and I have no doubt that he's done very thorough research into this role.
But he's not Sherlock Holmes.
I've watched the trailer a few times, and it looks like massive fun, but..he's too damn pretty, there's too much action, and he kisses a lady? Is left handcuffed in bed?
Even when I was writing Holmes fanfic as a teenager, I didn't go there.
And, to steal a phrasing from the Whovians, Jeremy Brett is "my" Holmes.
I'll watch this movie, and I already love the merchandising, but I rather wish they'd just gone with some other generic new detective and not Holmes.
ETA: It is a sad, sad testament to my geekitude that, while filling out this contest entry and seeing the title of "Prof" was listed in a drop down menu, I immediately wanted to fill out an entry for Prof Moriarity.
(Please let there be a few of you reading who would want to do the same thing.)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUQbmFAE5WI
Ok, so.
I adore RDJ. I think he's brilliant. I've loved just about everything I've ever seen him do and I have no doubt that he's done very thorough research into this role.
But he's not Sherlock Holmes.
I've watched the trailer a few times, and it looks like massive fun, but..he's too damn pretty, there's too much action, and he kisses a lady? Is left handcuffed in bed?
Even when I was writing Holmes fanfic as a teenager, I didn't go there.
And, to steal a phrasing from the Whovians, Jeremy Brett is "my" Holmes.
I'll watch this movie, and I already love the merchandising, but I rather wish they'd just gone with some other generic new detective and not Holmes.
ETA: It is a sad, sad testament to my geekitude that, while filling out this contest entry and seeing the title of "Prof" was listed in a drop down menu, I immediately wanted to fill out an entry for Prof Moriarity.
(Please let there be a few of you reading who would want to do the same thing.)